Brother Bartholomew: an appreciation.
Today I received the sad news that Brother Bartholomew has passed away at the ripe old age of 95. As an ex student of his I feel his loss keenly. He was a giant of a man, both physically (6 foot 5 inches in his stocking feet) and spiritually. As one of the five remaining Christian Brothers left in Ireland, his passing is a poignant and important footnote in our history.
For my own part I remember him with great fondness. Unfortunately there are those who will seek to re-interpret his career for their own unseemly motives. They will point and judge, and talk solely about the inexplicable and unpredictable bouts of rage, the damaged classroom furniture, and that slight misunderstanding around the events of May 1985.
In regard to the latter incident, may I say that describing an intense pre-exam cramming session as a “three day siege” was at best somewhat wide of the mark, and at worst morally reprehensible. The partisan and hysterical coverage in the Irish Times was particularly despicable. Granted, the "negotiations", as some have termed them, were long and fraught. But where the education of children is concerned, I think any reasonable person can forgive a little over exuberance on the part of the teacher in question. And that is precisely what Judge Allen did in his lengthy and considered judgement.
Many have spoken of the incidents of Brother Bartholomew’s so called volatile behaviour. I say these were merely the superficial outward manifestations of a deeply felt ideology. They were transitory and unorthodox, and are best remembered in a quirky light against the broader backdrop of one man’s life dedicated to the improvement of others. Let us forgo the knee-jerk judgements so beloved of liberal elements and remember him in the light of our shared humanity. Indeed, who among us can say we haven’t accidentally dropped a more annoying “open-minded” colleague out of a third floor window.
When last we met he was as forceful as ever, despite being well into his sixties. I can still see his stern blue eyed gaze, his beak like nose, and his traditional black garb lightly streaked with chalk dust. I remember the sudden inexplicable urge to recount my twelve times tables, and the involuntary raising of my arm to protect my face.
“Have no fear,” he said to me. “My duster throwing days are well behind me.”
He then leaned in and whispered in my ear “Although I’m still not beyond a good sharp dig in the ribs.”
We chuckled, and to illustrate his point he made a feinting motion as if to karate chop me in the midriff. I pretended to dodge the blow. We chuckled some more. Oh yes indeed, how we laughed.
Then he kneed me in the groin.
He was a traditionalist, both in technique and temperament. Some of the more namby pamby elements of contemporary society might term his techniques as “outmoded” and “excessively brutal”, but I prefer to think of him as an educational innovator. I firmly believe his misunderstood, and oh so subtly aggressive pedagogy has gone underappreciated for far too long.
Tighter more constricting à la mode definitions would probably see him unfairly labelled as a low level psychopath. I prefer to think that these stricter definitions are the product of a secularised industrial pharmacological complex intent on spreading its malign influence by whatever means necessary. They ignore the whole man, and seek to delete from history any positive mentions of his encouraging influence on generations of children. I know this to be the case, because there are never any positive mentions of his encouraging influence on generations of children. Again the words “three day siege” spring to mind, and it merely re-affirms for me how far some people will go to blacken a good man’s name by re-writing history for their own nefarious ends.
Whatever you do today take a moment’s contemplation to appreciate what we’ve all lost. We are all a little poorer for his passing. He leaves behind a rich personal history, an important educational legacy, four remaining Christian Brothers, and an under 12s football team now looking for a new coach. We shall never see his like again. And more’s the pity.
May he rest in peace.
